When the first “hobbit” or Homo floresiensis skeleton was found in 2003 in a cave on the island of Flores, it made headlines around the world. But it didn’t take long for the arguing to begin. Did this small skeleton represent a whole new kind of hominin? A petite species that was still around as recently as 12,000 YBP, long after the Neandertals had disappeared? Or was it just the remains of some poor soul with a severe pathology? Scientists tossed around all sorts of ideas about which disorders could result in a person growing to only about a meter tall, with a tiny skull and a curious resemblance to Homo erectus. An Indonesian paleoanthropologist named Teuku Jacob was one of the first scientists who suggested the skeleton could belong to someone suffering from microcephaly. Soon after the remains were discovered, he “borrowed” them, taking them from the center where they were kept and bringing them to his own laboratory. This caused an uproar. Eventually, he returned the hobbit remains to the researchers who found them, but they had been severely damaged. Among other things, the pelvis was smashed and several important bones were missing. As if that wasn’t bad enough, in 2005, Indonesia forbade researchers access to the cave where the hobbit was found. It wasn’t until Jacob’s death a couple of years later that research there was allowed to resume. And the colorful history of the hobbit finds doesn’t end there. Maciej Henneberg, Robert Eckhardt, and John Schofield self-published a book called The Hobbit Trap, in which they called into question the status of the hobbit as a new species. One of their objections was that the teeth showed signs of modern dental work, a claim Peter Brown (one of the hobbit’s discoverers) understandably called “complete lunacy.” Nevertheless, this claim enjoyed a lot of attention from the media. Some people have even speculated that species like H. floresiensis may still be hidden away in remote corners of the world–apparently, rumors of tiny people abound in Indonesia, and in particular, on Flores. I wish we lived in a world where finding another hominin tucked away somewhere seemed like a real possibility!
When the Flores remains were found, the hypothesis that they could have resulted from microcephaly or cretinism was reasonable. After all, when the first Neandertal remains found, people thought maybe they belonged to a Cossack soldier with rickets. In the case of the hobbit, as in the case of that first Neandertal, there was just the one skeleton–and it’s hard to be sure about a new species designation from a single set of bones. But in-depth study of the skull recovered from the cave demonstrated that its features resembled those of archaic humans. And comparisons to skulls of people suffering from the proposed disorders showed that there wasn’t a good match. Eventually nine tiny sets of remains spanning 3,000 years were discovered in the cave, providing pretty strong evidence that the original find didn’t belong to an isolated individual suffering from a disease. And, early this year, a team of researchers showed that two different Homo floresiensis specimens had wrist bones distinct enough from ours to warrant a separate species designation.
What else do we know about the hobbits? Researchers think their short stature may have resulted from “island dwarfism,” a tendency of species to shrink over many generations once they have arrived on an island. A study published this April in Proceedings of the Royal Society by Yousuke Kaifu and colleagues suggests that this idea is reasonable and that the process could have resulted in the hobbit’s body plan. We don’t know much about what life was like for the hobbits, but it may not have been so different from what Homo sapiens were doing around the same time. Possible evidence of stone tools and cooking has been found in their cave. Some scientists believe that a volcanic eruption on Flores may have wiped out both the hobbits and the island’s Stegodon, a species of dwarf, elephant-like creatures that the hobbits liked to hunt. Although Svante Paabo has worked magic in the past, teasing the Neandertal and Denisova genomes out of ancient remains, no one has been able to coax usable DNA from the hobbit remains yet. I am hopeful that the future will reveal additional Hobbit specimens, though, and that one of them may yield DNA suitable for sequencing. Maybe we will find that, like the Denisovans and the Neandertals, hobbit genes live on in us. Wouldn’t THAT be exciting?